net_left adver left
Detail

Analysis: Banks are Twitter-deal escape hatch that Musk would struggle with

By Anirban Sen and Greg Roumeliotis (Reuters) - The banks that agreed to finance Elon Musk's $44 billion acquisition of Twitter Inc (NYSE:TWTR) have a financial incentive to...
Analysis: Banks are Twitter-deal escape hatch that Musk would struggle with © Reuters. FILE PHOTO: An image of Elon Musk is seen on smartphone placed on printed Twitter logos in this picture illustration taken April 28, 2022. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo

By Anirban Sen and Greg Roumeliotis

(Reuters) - The banks that agreed to finance Elon Musk's $44 billion acquisition of Twitter Inc (NYSE:TWTR) have a financial incentive to help the world's richest person walk away but would face long legal odds, according to people close to the deal and corporate law experts.

Twitter has sued Musk to force him to complete the transaction, dismissing his claim that the San Francisco-based company misled him about the number of spam accounts on its social media platform as buyer's remorse in the wake of a plunge in technology stocks.

The Delaware Court of Chancery, where the dispute between the two sides is being litigated, has set a high bar for acquirers being allowed to abandon their deals, and most legal experts have said the arguments in the case favor Twitter.

Yet there is one scenario in which Musk would be allowed to abandon the acquisition by paying Twitter only a $1 billion break-up fee, according to the terms of their contract. His $13 billon bank financing for the deal would have to collapse.

Refusing to fund the deal would weigh on the banks' reputation in the market for mergers and acquisitions as reliable sources of debt. However, the banks would have at least two reasons to help Musk get out of the acquisition, three sources close to the deal said.

The banks stand to earn lucrative fees from Musk's business ventures such as electric car maker Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA) Inc and space rocket company Space, provided they continue to curry favor with him.

They also face the prospect of hundreds of millions of dollars in losses if Musk is forced to complete the deal, the sources said. This is because, as with every big acquisition, the banks would have to sell the debt to get it off their books.

They would struggle to attract investors given the downturn in pockets of the debt market since the deal was signed in April, and the fact that Musk would be seen as an unwilling buyer of the company, the sources said. The banks would then face the prospect of selling the debt at a loss.

It is unclear whether the banks that agreed to finance the acquisition -- Morgan Stanley (NYSE:MS), Bank of America Corp (NYSE:BAC), Barclays (LON:BARC) Plc, Mitsubishi UFJ (NYSE:MUFG) Financial Group Inc, BNP Paribas (OTC:BNPQY) SA, Mizuho Financial Group Inc and Societe Generale (OTC:SCGLY) SA -- will attempt to get out of the deal.

The banks are waiting for the outcome of the legal dispute between Musk and Twitter before making any decisions, according to the sources. The trial is scheduled to start in October.

Spokespeople for Morgan Stanley, Bank of America, Barclays, Mitsubishi and Mizuho declined to comment, while BNP Paribas and Societe Generale did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

There is a catch to the banks serving as Musk's escape hatch. He would have to show in court that the banks refused to deliver on their debt commitments despite his best efforts, according to the terms of his deal contact with Twitter.

This would be challenging to prove given Musk's public statements against the deal as well as private communications between Musk and the banks that Twitter may uncover in its request for information, four corporate lawyers and professors interviewed by Reuters said.

"Musk would have to convince the judge he is not responsible for the bank financing falling through. That is hard to show, it would require a great degree of deftness from him and the banks," said Columbia Law School professor Eric Talley.

Musk and Twitter representatives did not respond to requests for comment.

HUNTSMAN PRECEDENT

Even if the banks can show they are not acting at Musk's behest, they would find it difficult to get out of the Twitter deal, the legal experts said. They pointed to the case of chemical maker Hunstman Corp, which in 2008 sued the banks that walked away from financing its $6.5 sale to Hexion Specialty Chemicals.

Hexion, owned by private equity firm Apollo Global Management (NYSE:APO) Inc, abandoned the deal after Huntsman (NYSE:HUN)'s fortunes deteriorated, but a Delaware judge ruled that the transaction should go ahead. The two banks financing the deal, Credit Suisse Group AG and Deutsche Bank AG (NYSE:DB), then refused to fund it, arguing the combined company would be insolvent.

Huntsman sued the banks and, one week into the trial, they settled. The banks agreed to a $620 million cash payment and the provision of a $1.1 billion credit line to Hunstman, which had also secured earlier a $1 billion settlement payment from Apollo.

The banks balking at funding Musk's deal would also have to show that Twitter would be insolvent if the acquisition happened, or that terms of their debt commitment were somehow breached, a high bar based on the deal documents that have been made public, the legal experts said.

"If the banks try to get out of the deal, they will walk into the same fight that Musk has taken on, where Twitter has the better legal arguments," said Eleazer Klein, co-chair of law firm Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP's mergers, acquisitions and securities group.

HOT AUTO TRADE BOT SOFTWARE adver right
APPROVED BROKERS
net_home_top HOT AUTO TRADE BOT SOFTWARE
16-08-2022 20:01:45 (UTC+7)

EUR/USD

1.0146

-0.0014 (-0.14%)

Summary

↑ Buy

Moving Avg:

Buy (12)

Sell (0)

Indicators:

Buy (8)

Sell (0)

EUR/USD

1.0146

-0.0014 (-0.14%)

Summary

↑ Buy

Moving Avg:

Buy (12)

Sell (0)

Indicators:

Buy (8)

Sell (0)

GBP/USD

1.2052

-0.0002 (-0.02%)

Summary

↑ Buy

Moving Avg:

Buy (12)

Sell (0)

Indicators:

Buy (7)

Sell (0)

USD/JPY

134.59

+1.26 (+0.95%)

Summary

↑ Buy

Moving Avg:

Buy (10)

Sell (2)

Indicators:

Buy (6)

Sell (2)

AUD/USD

0.7001

-0.0022 (-0.31%)

Summary

↑ Buy

Moving Avg:

Buy (10)

Sell (2)

Indicators:

Buy (5)

Sell (3)

USD/CAD

1.2890

-0.0014 (-0.11%)

Summary

↑ Sell

Moving Avg:

Buy (1)

Sell (11)

Indicators:

Buy (1)

Sell (8)

EUR/JPY

136.55

+1.10 (+0.81%)

Summary

↑ Buy

Moving Avg:

Buy (12)

Sell (0)

Indicators:

Buy (9)

Sell (0)

EUR/CHF

0.9641

+0.0027 (+0.28%)

Summary

Sell

Moving Avg:

Buy (6)

Sell (6)

Indicators:

Buy (1)

Sell (6)

Gold Futures

1,788.45

-9.65 (-0.54%)

Summary

↑ Sell

Moving Avg:

Buy (0)

Sell (12)

Indicators:

Buy (1)

Sell (10)

Silver Futures

19.957

-0.315 (-1.55%)

Summary

Neutral

Moving Avg:

Buy (4)

Sell (8)

Indicators:

Buy (6)

Sell (3)

Copper Futures

3.6215

+0.0040 (+0.11%)

Summary

↑ Buy

Moving Avg:

Buy (12)

Sell (0)

Indicators:

Buy (6)

Sell (1)

Crude Oil WTI Futures

89.48

+0.07 (+0.08%)

Summary

↑ Sell

Moving Avg:

Buy (0)

Sell (12)

Indicators:

Buy (0)

Sell (8)

Brent Oil Futures

94.96

-0.14 (-0.15%)

Summary

↑ Sell

Moving Avg:

Buy (0)

Sell (12)

Indicators:

Buy (0)

Sell (9)

Natural Gas Futures

9.316

+0.588 (+6.74%)

Summary

↑ Buy

Moving Avg:

Buy (12)

Sell (0)

Indicators:

Buy (7)

Sell (0)

US Coffee C Futures

223.85

-1.65 (-0.73%)

Summary

↑ Sell

Moving Avg:

Buy (5)

Sell (7)

Indicators:

Buy (1)

Sell (7)

Euro Stoxx 50

3,792.35

+2.73 (+0.07%)

Summary

Neutral

Moving Avg:

Buy (4)

Sell (8)

Indicators:

Buy (3)

Sell (3)

S&P 500

4,297.14

+16.99 (+0.40%)

Summary

Neutral

Moving Avg:

Buy (6)

Sell (6)

Indicators:

Buy (3)

Sell (4)

DAX

13,843.02

+26.41 (+0.19%)

Summary

Neutral

Moving Avg:

Buy (6)

Sell (6)

Indicators:

Buy (5)

Sell (1)

FTSE 100

7,548.15

+39.00 (+0.52%)

Summary

↑ Sell

Moving Avg:

Buy (0)

Sell (12)

Indicators:

Buy (0)

Sell (8)

Hang Seng

19,830.52

-210.34 (-1.05%)

Summary

↑ Buy

Moving Avg:

Buy (10)

Sell (2)

Indicators:

Buy (9)

Sell (0)

US Small Cap 2000

2,020.40

+7.30 (+0.36%)

Summary

↑ Buy

Moving Avg:

Buy (12)

Sell (0)

Indicators:

Buy (7)

Sell (1)

IBEX 35

8,482.83

+55.83 (+0.66%)

Summary

↑ Sell

Moving Avg:

Buy (0)

Sell (12)

Indicators:

Buy (0)

Sell (8)

BASF SE NA O.N.

44.182

+0.122 (+0.28%)

Summary

Neutral

Moving Avg:

Buy (5)

Sell (7)

Indicators:

Buy (6)

Sell (1)

Bayer AG NA

54.05

+0.49 (+0.91%)

Summary

↑ Sell

Moving Avg:

Buy (4)

Sell (8)

Indicators:

Buy (0)

Sell (8)

Allianz SE VNA O.N.

179.57

+0.79 (+0.44%)

Summary

Neutral

Moving Avg:

Buy (3)

Sell (9)

Indicators:

Buy (4)

Sell (2)

Adidas AG

170.65

-2.29 (-1.32%)

Summary

Buy

Moving Avg:

Buy (6)

Sell (6)

Indicators:

Buy (6)

Sell (1)

Deutsche Lufthansa AG

6.723

-0.011 (-0.16%)

Summary

Neutral

Moving Avg:

Buy (4)

Sell (8)

Indicators:

Buy (9)

Sell (0)

Siemens AG Class N

111.23

-0.97 (-0.86%)

Summary

Sell

Moving Avg:

Buy (1)

Sell (11)

Indicators:

Buy (3)

Sell (4)

Deutsche Bank AG

8.988

+0.046 (+0.51%)

Summary

↑ Buy

Moving Avg:

Buy (8)

Sell (4)

Indicators:

Buy (6)

Sell (0)

    EUR/USD 1.0146 ↑ Buy  
    GBP/USD 1.2052 ↑ Buy  
    USD/JPY 134.59 ↑ Buy  
    AUD/USD 0.7001 ↑ Buy  
    USD/CAD 1.2890 ↑ Sell  
    EUR/JPY 136.55 ↑ Buy  
    EUR/CHF 0.9641 Sell  
    Gold 1,788.45 ↑ Sell  
    Silver 19.957 Neutral  
    Copper 3.6215 ↑ Buy  
    Crude Oil WTI 89.48 ↑ Sell  
    Brent Oil 94.96 ↑ Sell  
    Natural Gas 9.316 ↑ Buy  
    US Coffee C 223.85 ↑ Sell  
    Euro Stoxx 50 3,792.35 Neutral  
    S&P 500 4,297.14 Neutral  
    DAX 13,843.02 Neutral  
    FTSE 100 7,548.15 ↑ Sell  
    Hang Seng 19,830.52 ↑ Buy  
    Small Cap 2000 2,020.40 ↑ Buy  
    IBEX 35 8,482.83 ↑ Sell  
    BASF 44.182 Neutral  
    Bayer 54.05 ↑ Sell  
    Allianz 179.57 Neutral  
    Adidas 170.65 Buy  
    Lufthansa 6.723 Neutral  
    Siemens AG 111.23 Sell  
    Deutsche Bank AG 8.988 ↑ Buy  
Mua/Bán 1 chỉ SJC
# So hôm qua # Chênh TG
SJC Eximbank6,580/ 6,680
(-10/ -10) # 1,639
SJC HCM6,600/ 6,700
(-10/ -10) # 1,659
SJC Hanoi6,600/ 6,702
(-10/ -10) # 1,661
SJC Danang6,600/ 6,702
(-10/ -10) # 1,661
SJC Nhatrang6,600/ 6,702
(-10/ -10) # 1,661
SJC Cantho6,600/ 6,702
(-10/ -10) # 1,661
Cập nhật 16-08-2022 20:01:48
Xem lịch sử giá vàng SJC: nhấn đây!
ↀ Giá vàng thế giới
$1,773.33 -5.15 -0.29%
Live 24 hour Gold Chart
ʘ Giá bán lẻ xăng dầu
Sản phẩm Vùng 1 Vùng 2
RON 95-V25.34025.840
RON 95-III24.66025.150
E5 RON 92-II23.72024.190
DO 0.05S22.90023.350
DO 0,001S-V24.88025.370
Dầu hỏa 2-K23.32023.780
ↂ Giá dầu thô thế giới
WTI $88.93 -1.13 -1.28%
Brent $94.52 -1.56 -1.68%
$ Tỷ giá Vietcombank
Ngoại tệMua vàoBán ra
USD23.230,0023.540,00
EUR23.145,5524.441,71
GBP27.456,8428.627,78
JPY171,08181,12
KRW15,4318,80
Cập nhật lúc 18:54:08 16/08/2022
Xem bảng tỷ giá hối đoái
adver main right